Compare the final payout (after any fees), whether towing is included, pickup timing, payment method, and buyer reputation. The highest quoted price isn’t always the best deal if it comes with hidden costs, unreliable service, or payment delays.
Factors to compare across quotes:
- Final price after all fees (ask specifically about deductions)
- Free towing included (standard with reputable buyers)
- Payment timing (at pickup vs. mailed later)
- Payment method (cash, check, electronic transfer)
- Pickup availability (same-day, next-day, scheduled)
- Buyer reviews and reputation
- Price guarantee (will it change at pickup?)
Create a simple comparison:
- Buyer A: $450, free towing, cash at pickup, 4.5 stars, next-day pickup
- Buyer B: $500, free towing, check mailed in 5 days, 3.2 stars, pickup in 3 days
- Buyer C: $475, $50 towing fee, cash at pickup, 4.8 stars, same-day pickup
In this example, Buyer A might be the best choice despite not having the highest offer. Immediate payment, good reviews, and quick pickup often outweigh a small price difference.
If one quote is dramatically higher than others, be cautious. Learn about why offers vary to understand what drives pricing differences.
